**Should You Take Creatine Supplements? Here’s What You Need to Know**
Creatine supplements are everywhere these days, touted for their potential to improve both strength and cognitive function. But should you jump on the bandwagon? Let’s break down what the research says and whether creatine is right for you.
—
### What Is Creatine?
Creatine is a nonessential nutrient, meaning your body produces it naturally. It helps form adenosine triphosphate (ATP), a key energy source for your muscles and organs.
You can find creatine in supplements such as powders, gummies, and pills, but it’s also present in animal-derived foods like beef and seafood. Plant-based sources generally don’t contain significant amounts of creatine.
—
### Does Creatine Really Improve Strength?
Multiple randomized controlled trials have shown that creatine supplementation can lead to small but real increases in upper and lower body strength — but only **when combined with resistance training**. Without resistance training, creatine doesn’t offer any significant benefits.
For example, younger adults taking creatine while following a resistance training program improved their bench and chest press strength by approximately 4 pounds compared to training alone. While this may not seem life-changing for some, even small boosts can be meaningful for higher-risk groups.
—
### Who Benefits Most?
Creatine may offer added advantages for groups at higher risk of muscle loss, including:
– Postmenopausal women
– Adults taking GLP-1 medications
– Older adults in nursing homes
These groups should ensure they are doing enough resistance training before considering supplementation.
—
### Resistance Training: The Foundation
Before thinking about creatine, ask yourself: **Am I doing enough resistance training?**
Federal guidelines recommend strength-building exercises — such as sit-ups, push-ups, or weightlifting — at least two times per week. If you’re not meeting this minimum, creatine supplementation is unlikely to help.
If you are training regularly and fall into a higher-risk category or simply want a slight edge, it might be reasonable to discuss creatine with your physician.
—
### Bone Health and Creatine
Many hope creatine could improve bone mineral density, especially for postmenopausal women, potentially reducing fracture risks. However, long-term studies have not demonstrated clear benefits.
A large two-year randomized controlled trial found that creatine did not improve bone mineral density compared to placebo when combined with resistance training. While short-term studies showed some promising effects at the femoral neck (a common site for hip fractures), these benefits didn’t persist long-term.
That said, creatine may still have other positive effects, like increasing walking speed and improving the geometric arrangement of bone — factors that theoretically enhance bone strength.
—
### Performance Benefits
Creatine may help female athletes and older adults by providing short bursts of energy, improving performance in tasks like standing up from a chair multiple times in 30 seconds without using arms.
However, these benefits are generally small and should be viewed as supplementary to consistent exercise.
—
### Cognitive Function and Creatine: What We Know So Far
Research on creatine’s impact on cognitive function is still in its early stages and results are mixed. For instance, a 2013 randomized controlled trial found no improvement in cognition or depression among older women taking creatine supplements.
Conversely, some observational studies have noted positive associations between dietary creatine intake and memory in older adults. More research is needed to draw definitive conclusions.
—
### How Much Creatine Should You Take?
Always consult your physician before starting creatine, especially if you have kidney disease, as there is some evidence of potential risk for those with preexisting conditions.
Typical dosages include:
– **3-5 grams per day:** Effective long-term dose for healthy individuals.
– **5-10 grams per day:** May be optimal for women, particularly postmenopausal women.
– **Loading phase:** Some use about 20 grams daily (spread over 4-5 grams doses) for one week, then reduce to maintenance doses.
Muscle creatine stores typically reach saturation after about a month with daily doses of 3-5 grams.
—
### Combining Creatine with Protein Powder
Many people take both creatine and protein powders (whey, pea, soy) to support muscle recovery. Keep these points in mind:
– Protein powders provide essential amino acids that your body cannot make, so dietary intake matters. Most people get enough protein from food, but older adults, women, and highly active individuals should pay closer attention.
– The FDA does not regulate dietary supplements with the same rigor as prescription drugs. A Consumer Reports study found that many protein powders contained potentially unsafe lead levels. While this study did not include creatine powders specifically, it highlights the importance of cautious supplement use, particularly for pregnant women or other high-risk groups.
—
### Final Thoughts: What I Want My Patients to Know
Resistance training should be as integral to your health routine as eating fruits and vegetables. Unfortunately, many adults don’t meet recommended guidelines: less than half of men and about 27 percent of women engage in adequate resistance training.
Before considering creatine supplements, prioritize regular resistance exercise. Creatine can provide a small boost, but it’s **not a magic bullet**. The real “magic” is consistent, dedicated lifting and muscle-strengthening activity.
—
*For personalized advice, always consult your healthcare provider before starting any supplement regimen.*
https://newsindiatimes.com/as-a-doctor-heres-my-advice-on-creatine-supplements/
Be First to Comment